Simon

[Rswin]

Is it just me, or is Simon even more annoying this year?? Is it possible for the idiot to give an opinion without a STUPID analogy? Please, Lord make him stop!

[cwalton]

Yeah, he can be annoying, but I love his opinions because, as everyone boos him, he's right most of the time. I'd rather hear the truth than the syrup you usually get.

I still have big disconnects between what I think and what the judges think sometimes. Sometimes, I wonder if they heard the same song as I did.

Simon is usually the closest to my own opinion, so, ...I guess... he must be right... right?

[april_s]

I agree that Simon is usually right on! The one I can't stand is Paula. I have no idea what she is talking about sometimes. There is no constructive critism from her. If she were someone's coach, they would never get better she only tells them about the good things. I suppose that is what Simon is there for, between the two of them you get the critism and the positive.

Randy is cool- less repitition though