Second Episode

[cwalton]

The Second Episode is not better. Why did NO one vote for mutiny? That makes no sense. What are these people thinking? This smells like it's totally scripted and poorly written at that.

What do you think?

[Zagar]

Yep. There was really no reason to get rid of Christian that was shown. I am really thinking that this is truly scripted and that they drew marbles to see who would win the most money...

That could be why the application for this show was so strange. It was Survivors' app with SOME of the wording changed.... It was truly thrown together.......

[Brian Southworth]

Well I would hope that Mark Burnett would have more integrity than to script a show like this. But yeah, it does kinda stink. The premiss is ok. The pirates court thing is ok. Its definatly not survivor. When does China start??? Maybe Mark should do three seasons of survivor a year and can this show.

I'll keep watching to see how it plays out but so far its sortta, no its cheesy.

[Zagar]

Yeah, I liked Treasure Hunters from last summer better.... And you learned something of American History too!!!

[pawpaw]

Once BB starts PM is moving to Tuesdays at 10:00pm

[pawpaw]

Originally Posted by Brian Southworth

The premiss is ok. The pirates court thing is ok. Its definatly not survivor.

There's no face time--I can't put a name and a face for any of the girls together. The challange ended at 8:39, in survivor we would had people going off together, plotting, sidebars, ect.........slowly building up a personality behind each face. These people are hollow behind the mask.

Munity? If I hear Louie bad mouth the Capt and talk of munity but not be willing to do it himselve I'n going to sink their ship myselve!


Since the capt. was orginally to be on Survivor Guatamala, I think his great people skills would of made it a short stay!!

[Trisha B]

I personally think that the cast members are rather boring. They have no personality and not very lively. I don't understand why they didn't vote for mutiny if they have such a problem with the captain. I don't look for a second season of the show.

[Brian Southworth]

I think that in order to Mutiny it has to be unanimous. I think that they were going to do it until the cap mentioned that the Bosin had been paid and they may have changed their minds thinking that it wasn't going to be a unanimous decision. Thet may explaine it.

[zelda]

I dont understand where they are going with this show,

Do they have a destination that they are sailing to?
What are the rules to the boat?
Are they allowed to catch fish?
Are they allowed to share meals ?
What is the mental process of the "crew'" What are they thinking?

We the viewers are left with so many questions, we dont even know why the crew is making the choices they are making because there is no one on one interviews, all we know is that the guy who seemed the most likeable was voted off on the last episode and the jerk aka the Captain is lying around like a fat cat

I DONT GET IT