Retire these players!!

[Conor]

After this 20th season, retire all these players. We have seen some of these folks up to three times now they have had their chances. Can you imagine seeing some of tese guys a fourth or fifth time? Though we may love or hate or anywhere in between these guys I hope they start with a clean slate with the 21st season and give any new good players chances for returns.

What do our fellow fans say?

[Ceccara24]

don't bash some of my favorite players. don't worry they won't have another all-stars for a long time, if they even have one. I hope we get to see our favorite survivors come back time and again, James can get injured for a third consecutive time hehe

[Conor]

Originally Posted by Ceccara24

don't bash some of my favorite players. don't worry they won't have another all-stars for a long time, if they even have one. I hope we get to see our favorite survivors come back time and again, James can get injured for a third consecutive time hehe

hehe, I wasnt trying to bash anyone, I just feel all these players have had their chances and let the "Next generation" have their all stars and fans vs faves.
But James getting injured another time sounds good!
How about seeing some in another 20 years doing challenges with their walkers and canes, Russell finding multiple idols.

[pawpaw]

Originally Posted by Ceccara24

don't worry they won't have another all-stars for a long time, if they even have one.

Mark Burnett is saying that along with having 2 seasons filmed back to back the second one will be an ALLSTARS. So we will have allstars coming out of the ying yang.

[Ceccara24]

are you kidding me, another all-stars! this soon? hope its a joke! unless its all different people. either way it would be nice if they did some normal survivor for a couple seasons. I think that there should only be 1 all-stars every 10 seasons, and only people from that ten should be in it.

[pawpaw]

Originally Posted by Ceccara24

are you kidding me, another all-stars! this soon? hope its a joke! unless its all different people. either way it would be nice if they did some normal survivor for a couple seasons. I think that there should only be 1 all-stars every 10 seasons, and only people from that ten should be in it.

Even if we get the players that most people feel got left out--Judd, Shane, ect that only fills up 1 allstar. What would we have only 2 seasons later? I believe that formula of ever other allstar will kill survivor off.