Would you have kept the car?

[Diva]

I personally wouldn't have. If they all get as close as they claim they do, I'd want to give the 4 people I care about a car rather than give myself one. Maybe I'm too nice too..haha Although no guarantees, it probably would have allowed me to make the final 4.

[paddyteem]

There Is No Way I Would Have Kept The Car, If Four Other People Could Have One I Would Have Asked All To Chip In And Buy Me One Too And Then Everyone Would Have One. Five People Chipping In For One Is Better Than One Winning And Four Losing.... If This Wasnt Allowed Still Would Have Given Four People Cars Even If It Did Not Change Peoples Views. Each Player Already Knows What There Doing And Are All Playing The Game.. Some Smarter Than Others.

[greeneyez75]

I agree, no guarantees but a much higher liklihood that she'd have been safe for at least one more TC. Then, considering the fact that Cindy was pretty athletic and did well in most challenges, she might have won immunity, securing her spot in the final three. I mean, seriously, how much is a car like that worth? $30K, give or take? I don't know the amounts, but I do know they get paid according to thier finishing placement on the show, and I'd think that a sure thing for F4, and a strong possibility of F3, would have been worth risking that $30K vehicle. Of course, that's just my opinion. It also would have really sweetened the feelings of those four toward her, making it hared to vote against her if she were to make it to F2. I just don't think she was thinking clearly about it. She probably felt sort of vulnerable, being on the outside edge of a loose alliance that had already turned on two of it's supposed core members (Jamie and Judd). She probably felt like she should take whatever she could get since she wasn't going to win. My question is this: before the car incident, did any of the remaining players ever even mention voting her out? I think she was pretty safe. Too bad she didn't realize that.

Best part of the whole thing, though? Steph realizing that by voting Cindy out she had another betrayed jury member to deal with if she makes it to F2. She was counting the votes against her: Judd, Jamie, BJ, Gary, and now Cindy... It doesn't look good for her. The only person she could win against, in my opinion, is Lydia, because Lydia has been such a non-entity the entire game.

Cindy screwed up, but so did Steph, and I think it locked in a loss for her at F2.

[cherylb]

I would have kept the car. When all is said and done, you could give a car to the other tribe members, but still be voted off. You would have nothing they would each have a car a still a chance at being sole survivor. Look out for number 1, because if you don't no one else will. I also think Cindy would have been voted off anyway, then who would have haad the last laugh???

[jodiec]

If I was driving a bicycle there would be no way I would have kept the car for myself, I would have gave the others the vehicles for the simple fact of taking the chance that would be my ticket to the final four, there is always a chance that it would back fire but I feel being that close to the final four they would remember what I did and decieded that they could not vote me out, and if I got voted off anyway I still would have known that I did everything I possibly could to play the game fair! I know this is a game but some takes it alittle to far with their back-bitting other people like Stephanie has done throughout the episode she rode Judd's & Cindy's coat tail to get this far and stabbed both of them in the back! but hopefully she will be the next because Danni, Rafe, or Lydia is smart enough to see through her,,,,,oh poor, poor me (whinning) attitude.

[manwithintegrity]

Chances are she would have been able to KEEP her car just for being generous. Naturally, we'll never no. Goes to show that some people care more about themselves than others.

[Karma]

If Cindy were strategically thinking, she should have given the cars to the other players. She also should have taken Lydia, who seems to be the swing vote. All in all, I think Cindy messed up, and good riddance!

[huckleberry]

she did the right thing
keeping the car
but she should have taken lydia on the reward

[PGZ]

I personally wouldnt of kept the Vehicle. I would of given all the rest one. The reason being that if I did make it to the F2 3 of those people would have been on the jury.

Brownie points I guess but its a million bucks and thats the ultimate goal not the car.

PGZ

[cherylb]

Originally Posted by PGZ

I personally wouldnt of kept the Vehicle. I would of given all the rest one. The reason being that if I did make it to the F2 3 of those people would have been on the jury.

Brownie points I guess but its a million bucks and thats the ultimate goal not the car.

PGZ

That's still not a guarantee of anything. Could backfire, and then no million and no car