Right Winner or Not?

[cwalton]

Right Winner or Not?

[cherylb]

Not Not Not Not Not Not Not Not Not

[Twilight]

As soon as Danni took Steph instead of Rafe, soley so she could beat her, this turned into another Maquesa season for me.

[lovechild]

Originally Posted by Twilight

As soon as Danni took Steph instead of Rafe, soley so she could beat her, this turned into another Maquesa season for me.

"Soley so she could beat her"??? Isn't that the whole objective of staying out in the jungle with croc infested water, no food other than nasty corn, and weather enough to drive you insane?

Good golly - but I just can't believe she would want to take someone she knew would basically hand her the other $900,000.

The biggest point Stepha-me earned in my eyes this season was to be honest about how this game is played when she gave her answers to the jury... you go to win and know that there is going to be some lying, some trade-offs and some backstabbing.

[graceslick]

Stephanie lied and used people. I liked her at first, but she tricked everyone into treating her like royalty, taking her on the rewards, and giving her food. Then she cries like a baby when she thinks she has totally lost. She stepped on everyone all the way through, and they trusted her until the end.

[SurvivorNut]

The Right person won, plus by a 6-1 vote. So I'd say that the jury was pretty unanmous about who they thought should win. Steph had to play the role of Backstabber from early on to make as far as she did.


Someday on this board we actually might have a full page with no Stephenie Threads. Trust me that day can't come soon enough.

[MyopinionandMe]

Danni outwitted them - I think Lydia should not have gone then the three girls could have fought it out - who knows Lydia could have outlasted them

[michultra]

Actually it was the right winner (better than Steph). ALthough I would have liked to see Rafe - thought he did brilliantly on the challenges and he played a clean game. And hurray! for him not eating the sacrificial chicken....he truly has morals. ALthough I could see why Lydia was so hungry- she never got any food from rewards.

[greeneyez75]

Yes, I would have been okay with either Rafe or Danni winning, but I'm happy it was Danni. I think Rafe's biggest mistake in this game, the only one he couldn't overcome, was letting Danni out of her promise. I see where he was coming from, wanting an even playing feild between he and Steph and all that, but the problem is simply this: If Steph wasn't smart enough to try to get the same sort of promise from Danni, then Rafe shouldn't have felt pity for her and given up his shot. That was Rafe's ace in the hole - either girl would have taken him to F2. He played his game smart enough to get that security, so why the hell should he have given it up? Morals, schmorals - it's not the same thing.

Anyway, Danni did the right thing by taking Steph. I think the right person won.

[mybabysmomma]

Cindy got the short end of the stick all the way around. At the first challenge where they had the "numbers" Cindy stood on that log with no cheers from her fellow tribe's mates, however Judd got several "Good going!" and "Way to go" from his team (the same one as Cindy's I might add). She also won challenges and was right there on several of the individual immunity challenges--she beat out big mouth Judd and the oh-so-great-Rafe and the wonderous Stefanie and glorious Danni yet seemed to go undetected.

I think that Cindy played an excellent game. She didn't lie, she didn't cheat, she was straight forward and tough. And to top it off, she lost her job to go on Survivor. She really would have looked like a jerk if she hadn't taken the car. I say, Way to Go Cindy!