The "perfect" Survivor

[pawpaw]

Deleted.......

[zelda]

Originally Posted by pawpaw

Jeff P. has basiclly said #16 is an All Star, added to the fact it is the last one Jeff is under contact for and the last one CBS has picked up it is most likely the last season.

So lets design the perfect Survivor season, everyone add something.

1} NO pervious winners or anyone from a final 4, last all stars showed winners were dead meat and lacked the hunger ( too many friends ) only people from Jury #5-10---people who were there longer enough for us to get to know them but till hungery & nasty.

next

I vote for Shi-Ann aka the SHE-DEVIL, I think she is witty,smart and determined, I also think that the guy fell into the fire, and killed porky the pig ( cant remember his name ) from Survivor Outback, was interesting,

[Trisha B]

Originally Posted by zelda

I vote for Shi-Ann aka the SHE-DEVIL, I think she is witty,smart and determined, I also think that the guy fell into the fire, and killed porky the pig ( cant remember his name ) from Survivor Outback, was interesting,

I think a good All Star cast would be to bring back the first and/or second people that got voted off each season and let them have another shot. Those people didn't even have a chance to play the game.

Anyone else?....................................

[zelda]

Originally Posted by Trisha B

I think a good All Star cast would be to bring back the first and/or second people that got voted off each season and let them have another shot. Those people didn't even have a chance to play the game.

Anyone else?....................................

I dunno, If I can recall correctly, the first castoff's were the older ones (Geriatric Island ) and the annoying ones( Run Away Screaming Island ) like that lady who SANG SONGS SHE MADE UP, Life isnít fair, lets at least make it interesting, I'd prefer to hand pick my castaway

[cherylb]

Now, I'm going the opposite way. get the 1st and 2nd place winners for all stars and see who REALLY wins and deserves the title of sole survivor.

[zelda]

Originally Posted by cherylb

Now, I'm going the opposite way. get the 1st and 2nd place winners for all stars and see who REALLY wins and deserves the title of sole survivor.

That would be interesting however do we really wanna see sleezy Car Salesman that won Survivor Thailand, how about subjecting the players to a nude Richard Hatch for a third time, Would you wanna sit on the same stump He sat on with His naked be-hind? It would give me chills,Yuck. Jenna already quit once, Frankly I would be bored with Tina, Ethan and Steph for a 3rd go round, Lil ( Yawn ) Your Idea is good, the cast is bad, although I would love to see Tom again.

[cherylb]

Zelda, you make a good point, and some of them were tourtuos (sp) to watch the first time. Although, I don;t think the state pen would let Hatch out. How about this, all the past "characters" that most of us have bashed in the past (I couldn;t think of a nice way to say crazies) , i.e. Shane, Jonny Fairplay, Susan Hawk, Lisi, Janu, etc., etc.

And as always, as not to offend, this is just my opinion.

[zelda]

Originally Posted by cherylb

Zelda, you make a good point, and some of them were tourtuos (sp) to watch the first time. Although, I don;t think the state pen would let Hatch out. How about this, all the past "characters" that most of us have bashed in the past (I couldn;t think of a nice way to say crazies) , i.e. Shane, Jonny Fairplay, Susan Hawk, Lisi, Janu, etc., etc.

And as always, as not to offend, this is just my opinion.

LOVE IT! Pleeeeze can we just add in one other tidbit, that would be BOOZE! all they can drink, they would play for chicken wings and Nachos, no digging for a woosy idol they would have to win immunity in a fight club night YEH!

[Trisha B]

Originally Posted by zelda

LOVE IT! Pleeeeze can we just add in one other tidbit, that would be BOOZE! all they can drink, they would play for chicken wings and Nachos, no digging for a woosy idol they would have to win immunity in a fight club night YEH!

Hmmmmmmm Zelda, that could be a very interesting one. How about your idea and add in whoever is still standing, after an all night drinking binge, gets to pick who is the next to go home.
~or~
Get them all drunk then make them do a physical challenge. The first one out of the challenge gets to say bye-bye to the rest.
I really think that CBS should let us viewers vote for the next All Star cast. We could really have some fun with it.

[zelda]

Back to Reality, If I had to choose on who would make for interesting viewing it would have to be the following people,
Mike (fell in the fire guy) Outback
Rafe ñ Guatemala
Shi-Ann ñ Thailand
Rob C ñ Amazon
Bruce ñ The teacher with the bad bowels
Ami and Chad ñVanuatu
Sean and The General ñMarquesas
Their comments were interesting and they were played the game without needing to ride someoneís coat tails. There are many players who are much more likeable, but I think for interesting TV it would be this bunch
'Anyone else ?