Who SHOULD have won?

[cwalton]

Who SHOULD have won?

Tell us why. I think it should have been anyone but Parvati. What do you think?

[survivorman in Cali]

Chet, definitely, Chet. He was real good at playing possum. He mastered the rope a dope move and until injury took him out, he was allowing people to carry him to the finish line where his fresh legs will then have allowed him to dominate the individual challenges....

ok, all kididng aside, reallistically, Amanda should have won it. I'm surprised she lost to Parvati. I think she would have lost to Cirie as well. I think Amandas loyalties are her downfalls, she would have been better off taking Natalie or Erik to the final two......I do like the way she played the game. Aside from manipulating Erik, which was fine because he bailed on her first, she stayed loyal to those that she said she'd be loyal to.

[pawpaw]

Amanda


Amanda lost because jury members believe they belong in the F2 so the people in the F2 either cheated, lied, backstabbed, ect.... their way there over better people ( AKA themselves ) What Amanda has done wrong 2 straight TC has said she is sorry for evicting them--this translates to the jury as I'm sorry I was better than you. You do what Todd did last year--I evicted all of you anyway I could because it was the only way to beat such great players ( think Jean Robert ).

What was Amansa to do with this jury? They didn't ask her questions, they vented.

Eliza --your voice makes me want to kill myself. Hard to think of an answer to get her vote

Alexis--Your phony and fake looking

Natalie--You look funny.

Cirie--You didn't say I was the greatest player ever.

[cherylb]

I would have voted for the chicken over Parvati. Parvati is an OK player, but I think some of the other players were just better. I for one, didn't like the flirting she did, tried to do, or thought about doing. Out of the F2, of course I would have voted for AManda,, if it were Amanda or CIrie, it would have been Cirie (not the most athletic, but always under the radar, and did the best she could under any circumstances). Ozzy, I still think is the best player, athletically, and his social game did pick up since last time. But, what's done is done.

[cherylb]

After thinking about it some more (first cup of coffee ), suggesting Gloria over Parvati was not nice. So, who should have won other than Parvati, everyone who had to live with her, the million should have been devided up among them. Honestly, I think she is proud of the fact that she is a flirt, and would do ANYTHING (ahem) to further herself in the game. I, personally just think it's wrong. And, if I had a daughter who looked up to her as a role model, I'd be looking up convent schools., immediately!!!!!

[sindian]

I wouldn't have minded Amanda winning, but I don't think Parviti should have won, she really didn't do much to me. I think Cirie really got hosed, not because she didn't win but because she didn't get the credit she deserves for the incredible game she played. For the most part she didn't have an alliance till late. When Joel was talking about getting rid of the weakest and Chet, she turned it around and said "If he wants to start with the weakest, then im on the list" So she changed it and got rid of Joel. Then she decided they should get rid of Ozzy or at least have him play the idol. Same with Jason...I believe thats his name..who went the same way as Ozzy. Who was the one to suggest to the girls/Natalie to have Erik give up the idol...Erik wouldn't have done that if he didn't talk to Cirie...I mean Nat played her part good but Cirie master minded so many things.

[newfmom]

AMANDA! I can't believe Parvati won over Amanda!! We were all yelling, "NO" when Jeff announced the winner was Parvati! All that girl did was flirt, hardly did any work, she was not the best player! I guess too many jury members were mad at Amanda for "playing up" that she did not have the immunity idol when she did - yet - that's part of the game! (That was a brilliant move though) Amanda should have pointed out more how devious Parvati was - Ozzy knew that and said so when it was his turn to speak. I'm VERY disappointed that Parvati won. Amanda is the winner as far as I'm concerened

[heyyou]

I was VERY VERY surprised that Parvarti won, total shock! Even though I don't particularly like her I think Cirie played a better game than Parv did. Amanda should have stuck up for herself more in TC but I guess by that time she was an emotional wreck. She shouldn't have agonized so much at having to vote one of the final 3 out, we ALL knew it was going to be Cirie. Wimping out at the end is not a good idea.

I agree with Pawpaw and was also surprised that the jury didn't seem to ask many questions. I thought Ozzy was a pretty poor sport there when he was ranting at Parv - after all he would have voted her out if it kept him in the game longer.

Who SHOULD have won? My vote is for Erik. Maybe with the million dollars he could have bought himself some brains, LOL.

[pawpaw]

Originally Posted by heyyou

I thought Ozzy was a pretty poor sport there when he was ranting at Parv - after all he would have voted her out if it kept him in the game longer.

This is the problem with returning players--they are friends outside the game. Remember all stars, Ethan was pissed because Lex voted him off ( they were friends in the real world )

[Grasshoppa]

Who should have won? ME!

Aside from that, if Erik wouldn't have been such a fool he would have had a really good chance at becoming a millionaire and buying his own ice cream parlor.